the Accordion Family Reading Discusses the "Boomerang Arrangement". This Is:

• Dwelling house
• My Books

Open Preview

See a Problem?

Nosotros'd love your assistance. Let united states know what'due south wrong with this preview of The Accordion Family by Katherine S. Newman.

Thanks for telling us nigh the problem.

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, delight sign up.

Community Reviews

 · 63 ratings  · 10 reviews

Outset your review of The Accordion Family: Boomerang Kids, Anxious Parents, and the Individual Toll of Global Competition

The author explores the phenomenon of adults in their twenties and thirties still living in their parents' homes in the world'southward wealthiest countries.

She looks at globalization and how it has changed the economic and cultural landscapes worldwide. It has raised the cost of living and created high unemployment rates that have served every bit barriers to adulthood and independence. As a upshot, families are opening up their homes to young adults, many of whom volition be tapping into parents' nest eggs with

The writer explores the phenomenon of adults in their twenties and thirties withal living in their parents' homes in the world's wealthiest countries.

She looks at globalization and how it has changed the economic and cultural landscapes worldwide. It has raised the cost of living and created high unemployment rates that have served as barriers to adulthood and independence. Every bit a result, families are opening up their homes to immature adults, many of whom will be tapping into parents' nest eggs with no means of their own when their parents depart.
Newman studied six countries: The United States, Italy, Nihon, Espana, and the Nordic countries of Sweden and Denmark. While each has seen an increment in "accordion families," they view it differently. The Spanish blame their government and big business organization. The Japanese expect at the phenomenon with horror. They call these immature adults "parasite singles" and blame parents. In Italia, the "cult of mammismo," mamma's boys, is accepted, even if the Italian authorities opposes information technology.
Newman'due south research goes into the homes within these countries with interviews and links globalization with the rise in squeeze box families. She concludes that nations with potent welfare states (the Nordic countries) accept petty or none of these families. The contrary holds true for those with weak welfare states.
The trouble: A lower fertility rate resulting in less workers to behave out the economy and to pay into the alimony systems. A partial abatement to this is immigration. The other is for a strong social democracy.

I establish it interesting reading, for I see this miracle every solar day with friends, neighbors and relatives. I am not comfortable with some of the conclusions Newman reaches, nonetheless. It may be too simplified every bit comparing a land such as Japan to Denmark may be one of apples and oranges. She selected four countries that take seen the largest increase in squeeze box families so pitted them against 2 where there are near non-real. Somehow it seems that her option bias would skew some of the conclusions presented. Are there countries with social policies and programs like to the Nordic countries? If and then are their numbers of accordion families also similar? I would have like to accept seen accordion family data data and comparisons of social programs from Canada, Korea, and some other European countries such as France and Frg. Are there regional differences in the United States? Furthermore, she states that the Us has been buffered somewhat past immigrants' contribution to the economy. Does she accept numbers? If then, I would similar to see them.

Besides, for those cases that I am very familiar with, causes of children returning to their parents' homes or even not leaving, are legion and various. Globalization may have some effect, but I suspect not the sole cause. Equally the book went on, her bias became more credible. I enjoyed information technology, notwithstanding. If this were a solely a descriptive work, I would take enjoyed information technology more than.

...more

Aug 05, 2019 Frrobins rated it it was ok

I was glad to exist done with this book. It was rather repetitive, dry out, and included a lot of interviews, and I don't like reading interviews. The first chapter was basically asking a bunch of different people what it means to be an adult and reading all of their different thoughts. If you lot are interested in this philosophical question it might have been interesting, merely I was not. And as an older millennial who managed to only boomerang dorsum into my parents house for a few weeks after graduating co I was glad to be done with this book. It was rather repetitive, dry, and included a lot of interviews, and I don't like reading interviews. The first affiliate was basically asking a bunch of dissimilar people what information technology means to be an adult and reading all of their different thoughts. If you are interested in this philosophical question it might accept been interesting, but I was not. And equally an older millennial who managed to only boomerang back into my parents house for a few weeks after graduating higher before moving out, getting a job, getting married and having kids and who striking those milestones and is still not certain if I feel like an adult, I didn't encounter the point of it.

The book focused on how all over the developed world developed children are moving back in with their parents. Places she focused on where Newton, America, Japan, Italy, Espana and the Nordic countries. The Nordic countries beingness an exception to the accordion family trend because of the safety net they take in place to forestall it. Part of the problem was I felt the telescopic was way too broad. While Ms. Newman did talk near the deviation between middle grade families trying to help their children get alee versus working class families who take to pool their resource to survive, this wasn't explored in tremendous depth. The other problem is that while Ms. Newman repeatedly states that globalization is the reason for the emergence of the piano accordion family unit and the reason immature people entering the workforce can't discover jobs, she never explains how globalization caused this.

And then the final chapter on declining nascence rates went on a bizarre tangent on immigration and assimilation which, while in our political times is rather relevant, didn't have much to do with multiple generations of families living under i roof, especially since she focused on the Nordic countries so heavily in this chapter. Reading almost the reasons for the low birth rate, people's attitudes towards information technology, or the differences between accordion families where the adult children have children of their own versus those that don't would take been more in line with the topic. Granted, the chapter gave some talking points for dealing with people who are anti-immigration and so it wasn't a full loss.

Once again, I was glad to exist washed with this book. I really tin't recommend information technology. There is some adept data, but the focus of the book was besides broad, it was so repetitive and I'1000 just not a fan of relying so heavily on interviews. Skip.

...more

Jan 30, 2019 Barbara rated it information technology was amazing

This was first-class, the economic effects of globalisation and fragmenting labour markets and the increasing cost of owner occupied housing and higher education and their effects of family life in a number of unlike countries. This would take taken a lot of empirical research put together into a very readable account.

Jul 09, 2012 Losososdiane rated information technology actually liked it

Interesting to read about comparisons of the various means nations and cultures deal with globalization and the devastating effect it has on the youth of the developed world. The differences between what the author labels the weak welfare states of Nippon, Italy and Kingdom of spain, and the social democracies of Scandinavia were startling to me. The author details the positives and negatives of the different approaches of the nations and the thinking of the citizens.

Comprehensive governmental (and thus tax

Interesting to read about comparisons of the diverse ways nations and cultures bargain with globalization and the devastating effect it has on the youth of the developed world. The differences between what the author labels the weak welfare states of Japan, Italia and Spain, and the social democracies of Scandinavia were startling to me. The writer details the positives and negatives of the different approaches of the nations and the thinking of the citizens.

Comprehensive governmental (and thus taxpayer) support in the social democracies mitigates after-revenue enhancement economic inequality only does not provide more than or ameliorate task opportunities for those new to the task market or those made redundant past technology or outsourcing, nor does it have a positive affect on social relationships, especially in families. Individualism is prized and the immature are able to exit dwelling at historic period 18 even without being able to support themselves. The demand to stay close to older generations is not fostered, marriage is not imperative and reproductive rates have dropped. The older generations manifestly release their immature people without further close contact on a regular basis. The consequence is quite a lot of social isolation.

Weak welfare states inadvertently foster strong family relationships. The young cannot afford to go out home until they are in their late 20s or even 30s. This reduces the motivation to marry and the reproductive birthrate drops alarmingly.

The need to maintain productivity and curb skyrocketing national debt opens the door for immigration from less developed areas of the earth. The new immigrants are not well-accustomed even though, until recently, they may have been well-supported, at least in the social democracies. Rising debt, increased medical costs and greater longevity is straining the budgets of these nations, leading to upkeep cuts and welfare cuts that reduce a social club's power to integrate the newcomers into the club, opening the mode to cultural and economic turmoil, crime and conflict, especially with the children of immigrants.

In addition, governments are relaxing requirements on corporations concerning employment, resulting in well-educated immature people finding it increasingly difficult to obtain full-time employment and/or a living wage. I would estimate that this is exacerbated by marketing and the media setting up impossible-to-fulfill wants and expectations about standards of living and material possessions which is perhaps good for selling things and getting people to get into debt to buy what they consider essentials only is terrible for getting the millennials out of the parental home and on their way to their own lives.

Overall, the information in this book terrifies me and makes me very sad. I am not nevertheless a grandmother and, subsequently reading this, I would be quite content to remain grandchildless. I tin can fully understand why birthrates have dropped and countries have go sort of tensely multicultural. The decisions and deportment at present required seem to exist incommunicable in a globe where the politicians require the large bucks and consequently the approving of the wealthy (the one pct?)to maintain their elected positions. The wealthy are, the writer points out and it seems obvious, insulated from what is happening and they want to maintain that command in which a greater and greater share of the wealth is in their hands. The caution to them is that when they sally from behind the gates of their multiple homes, they still must alive in this globe. We have tough decisions to make. I hope we tin practise information technology or I shall exit this world in a few years quite ashamed of the human race. Now I am off to read Robert Reich'south Aftershock where I do not look any relief!

...more

The Accordion Family: Boomerang Kids, Anxious Parents, and the Individual Toll of Global Contest addresses the phenomenon in Westernized, wealthy, industrialized countries of adult children in their twenties and thirties living with their parents for extended periods of time, breaking with the expectation of independence and financial cocky-sufficiency. Newman provides narrative data that supports her theory that globalization is a central factor that contributes to this phenomenon, and expands on t The Accordion Family: Boomerang Kids, Anxious Parents, and the Private Cost of Global Competition addresses the phenomenon in Westernized, wealthy, industrialized countries of adult children in their twenties and thirties living with their parents for extended periods of fourth dimension, breaking with the expectation of independence and financial cocky-sufficiency. Newman provides narrative data that supports her theory that globalization is a key factor that contributes to this phenomenon, and expands on that theory throughout her book.

I found the volume to be an interesting read, as I've observed this phenomenon among many of my students and, to some extent, in my own family unit. However, I recollect where Newman's book falls short is in its oversimplification of the issue. I'1000 sure that in that location are many more than factors in play, but I'll proper name two that come to heed for me:

First, the reality is that every decade (and every generation) is marked by an ever-irresolute set of cultural values, many of which are shaped by historical events, political attitudes, and the economic climate. I think that Newman passed upward a golden opportunity to explore the touch of growing upward in the postal service-9/11 era and in the age of personal applied science and social media. Moreover, we're increasingly in a media-saturated culture, which probably sets the tone for what "success" is in our society.

Secondly, the United states of america is by far the virtually individualistic country in the world. Our land has prided itself on the value of independence. However, in this economy, I think many youth and immature adults are running up against the limitations of an individualistic worldview. When we wait at immigrant families that come up to the United States, for instance, many of them go successful considering they capitalize on their collectivistic values. They live together (or in close proximity), they share household and child-care tasks, they share financial resources, and they build a community and cultural network. I recollect it would have been very interesting to explore this Western phenomenon amongst young adults from this angle.

...more than

The is a cross country disccussion and analysis of how globalization has lead to the increase in "boomerang kids" and "accordian families" wherein adult children live with their parents and delay matrimony and starting their own families. The most interesting part is how the countries civilisation frame this phenomenon. In Japan it is met with recrimination and the assumption of poor parenting; in Kingdom of spain it is clearly the economy and regime declining families and the youth, and in the U.S. it is acce The is a cross country disccussion and assay of how globalization has lead to the increase in "boomerang kids" and "accordian families" wherein adult children live with their parents and delay matrimony and starting their own families. The almost interesting part is how the countries civilisation frame this phenomenon. In Japan it is met with recrimination and the assumption of poor parenting; in Spain it is conspicuously the economic system and authorities failing families and the youth, and in the U.Southward. it is accepted as part of change and allowed if the developed child is working and trying to make leeway in other aspects of his/her professional life.

The author devotes a chapter to the Nordic countries of Northern Europe. Their liberal social democracies heavily subsidize education and housing so at eighteen most immature people can live on their own. It is the most interesting chapter because some people encounter this independence equally a sign that family bonds are weak and generations are besides isolated.

I learned lots of new things nigh every country (Japan didn't become the Pill until 199 or that the rental market in Spain is non-existant). I like that their was some discussion of class in relation to the U.South. and how poorer families depended on the income of multiple adults and adult children rarely movement out until subsequently. I admit I skimmed the chapter of declining birth rates and the needed yet feared and decried clearing rates.

If you liked Moneyball, but wished it was more than academic and used more facts, this book is an excellent complement on how the economy and recession is lived.

...more

Feb 26, 2012 Vicki Cline rated information technology really liked information technology

This volume talks about a relatively new phenomenon, developed children moving dorsum into the parents' domicile. Sometimes this is done after college while the graduate is looking for a job, and sometimes subsequently a divorce or foreclosure. Loftier unemployment effectually the world is causing near of this, and information technology'south evidently especially bad in Italian republic and Spain. The writer also has studied Japan, where it's an embarrassment to the parents, and the Scandinavian countries, where information technology'southward rare because of generous government s This book talks well-nigh a relatively new miracle, adult children moving dorsum into the parents' dwelling. Sometimes this is done after higher while the graduate is looking for a chore, and sometimes after a divorce or foreclosure. High unemployment around the world is causing most of this, and information technology's apparently especially bad in Italy and Espana. The author likewise has studied Japan, where it's an embarrassment to the parents, and the Scandinavian countries, where it's rare because of generous government subsidies which permit young people to alive on their ain, and also considering of a tradition of separation from the family when a youg person reaches adulthood. This is also causing lower birth rates in countries where information technology happens, considering of later marriages, and if immigration is restricted, to fewer workers contributing to growing numbers of retirees. Altogether, a very interesting expect at something I was only vaguely enlightened of. ...more

In a sociological study of families in the US, Italian republic and Nihon, Newman tracks the effect of parents caring for, housing and financially supporting both their parents and children. Interestingly, upper class and working class families have continued to do this as a affair of class or of economic necessity, simply for 200 years, the middle grade has increasingly defined itself by the ease with which their children establish separate, contained nuclear households and tailored their parenting and va In a sociological written report of families in the US, Italy and Japan, Newman tracks the effect of parents caring for, housing and financially supporting both their parents and children. Interestingly, upper class and working class families have connected to practice this every bit a matter of course or of economic necessity, but for 200 years, the eye class has increasingly defined itself by the ease with which their children establish divide, independent nuclear households and tailored their parenting and values to those ends (tolerating teenage rebellion equally a sign of independence, encouraging individuality). The global recession has turned that on its head, pushing together generations of people who never learned to live together and creating conflicts that people on the other ends of the social spectrum accept resentfully or smoothen over because of ingrained civilization. ...more

Oct 14, 2013 Jooyoung rated information technology really liked information technology

Kathy Newman is one of my favorite public ethnographers. She has an impressive range of knowledge on topics that are at the frontlines of public debate. From the working lives of the urban poor and the school shootings, to her almost recent work on "piano accordion families," Newman keeps finding interesting means to utilise her sociological imagination. I enjoyed reading about the experiences of twenty and thirtysomethings who decide to alive at home while they effigy out the rest of their lives. Her researc Kathy Newman is i of my favorite public ethnographers. She has an impressive range of knowledge on topics that are at the frontlines of public debate. From the working lives of the urban poor and the schoolhouse shootings, to her almost recent piece of work on "squeeze box families," Newman keeps finding interesting ways to employ her sociological imagination. I enjoyed reading about the experiences of xx and thirtysomethings who decide to alive at home while they figure out the rest of their lives. Her research spans different continents this time. Some of her respondents are from Japan, others from Italy, and and so some from the US. I particularly liked Chapter 3 "In-House Adulthood," because it delves into the more than practical dilemmas that young people face when they move domicile. ...more

Discipline: Adults effectually the earth who still alive with their parents.
Mode: Repetitive, redundant, reporting of statistics and anecdotes.
Summary: Without redeeming social value.

Caveat: Couldn't finish it, skipped to the conclusion, congratulated myself.

Subject: Adults around the earth who all the same live with their parents.
Style: Repetitive, redundant, reporting of statistics and anecdotes.
Summary: Without redeeming social value.

Caveat: Couldn't finish it, skipped to the conclusion, congratulated myself.

...more

Katherine Newman is Professor of Sociology and James Knapp Dean of the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences at Johns Hopkins University. Writer of several books on middle class economic instability, urban poverty, and the sociology of inequality, she previously taught at the Academy of California (Berkeley), Columbia, Harvard, and Princeton.

Related Articles

March is Women's History Month, dedicated to the written report, observance, and commemoration of the vital part of women in American history.   Some...

Welcome dorsum. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads business relationship.

clarkarpher.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/11794278-the-accordion-family

Share this post